How to respond when a logistics company blames you for damage
This playbook helps contractors respond when a third-party logistics company holds them financially responsible for property damage, installation problems, or product loss — often without solid proof.
Main goal
Force the company to produce actual evidence linking you to the damage, and build a counter-record using your own documentation.
Best first move
Request the full damage report in writing and immediately pull your own delivery photos, POD, and timestamps.
Do not do this
Do not verbally admit fault, agree to a repayment plan, or sign anything related to the claim before reviewing the evidence.
Step-by-step playbook
1. Do not admit fault — written or verbal
Any acknowledgment of responsibility, even casual, can be used against you. Until you have reviewed the claim fully, do not agree to anything in writing or on the phone.
2. Request the full damage report in writing
Ask for the specific damage report, the inspection records, photos taken by the company, and any third-party assessments. You have the right to see the basis for the claim.
3. Pull your own delivery documentation
Gather your delivery photos, POD confirmation, GPS or route data, any customer signatures, and timestamps. Your records are your first line of defense.
4. Analyze the timeline and chain of custody
Damage claims often fail when you can show the item left your hands intact. Map out every handoff, signature, and time gap after your delivery was completed.
5. Challenge the basis of the claim in writing
Send a formal written response disputing the claim. Cite the lack of evidence, point to your delivery documentation, and request the contract authority for the deduction or charge.
6. Escalate if the company doubles down
If they proceed without adequate proof, prepare a demand letter, an evidence index, and if needed, an arbitration filing to formally challenge the claim.
Gather these first
- Your delivery photos at drop-off
- Proof of delivery (POD) or customer signature
- GPS or route confirmation data
- Timestamps showing when delivery was completed
- The company's damage report and photos
- Your contractor agreement (look for damage claim provisions)
- Any communication about the damage claim
- Third-party inspection reports, if any
Recommended next tools
Documentation request letter
Dispute KitFormally demand the company provide their damage report, photos, and any inspection records.
Use This to Respond →Evidence checklist
Dispute KitOrganize your delivery proof, photos, POD data, and timeline before sending any response.
Use This Checklist →Arbitration prep
Case BuilderIf the company refuses to back down, get your case organized and ready for formal arbitration.
Prepare for ArbitrationDelivery Damage — Ready-to-Use Documents
Download the right letter for your situation
Each document is available as PDF (ready to send) and DOCX (editable).
Formal Demand for Reversal of Delivery Damage Charge
A formal written demand requiring the company to reverse a delivery damage charge. Establishes your delivery documentation, challenges their evidence, and sets a response deadline.
Post-Delivery Damage Rebuttal
Disputes a damage claim raised after delivery was confirmed. Documents the chain of custody and the absence of evidence linking you to the alleged damage.
Customer Presence and Acceptance Defense
Use when the customer was present and accepted the delivery. Formally places the customer's acknowledgment on record and challenges claims made after the fact.
Concealed Damage Response
Responds to concealed damage claims where damage was not visible at time of delivery. Forces the company to prove the damage occurred during your custody.
ClaimGuard Pro
Unlock the full dispute system
Templates, evidence tools, and arbitration prep — built for independent contractors. Dispute Kit starts at $39/month.